Miami-Dade

Economic crime

Florida: A Ponzi schemer’s paradise

 

How South Florida became synonymous with Ponzi schemes, financial fraud

How to protect your money

• Beware of high promised rates of return — guaranteed double-digit gains are fishy

• Research potential business partners thoroughly — check with napfa.org

• Consult an unbiased professional (an independent broker, etc.) before investing

• Do not give anyone direct access to bank or investment accounts

• If there’s a language barrier, find a translator you trust


Case studies

SCOTT ROTHSTEIN, 50

 Scheme size: $1.2 billion

Charges: Racketeering conspiracy, money laundering, mail and wire fraud

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to 50 years in federal prison

The skinny: Heavy-hitting Fort Lauderdale attorney dealt in bogus structured settlements, bought a golden toilet then ratted out the mob when it all went south.

NEVIN SHAPIRO, 43

 Scheme size: $930 million

Charges: Securities fraud

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to 20 years in federal prison

The skinny: UM booster lived like Caligula off proceeds from massive wholesale grocery scam. His Canes season tickets have been revoked.

JOEL STEINGER, 62, AND STEVEN STEINER, 60

 Alleged haul: $837 million

Charges: Money laundering, mail and wire fraud

Disposition: Awaiting trial

The skinny: These brothers (yes, spelled differently) allegedly ran the Fort Lauderdale-based Mutual Benefits scam, duping investors with faulty life insurance settlements.

BERNIE MADOFF, 74

 Scheme size: $65 billion

Charges: Securities, mail and wire fraud, money laundering and many others

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to 150 years in federal prison

The skinny: The biggest scammer of them, his victims included Miami car dealer Norman Braman and the owners of the New York Mets.

R. ALLEN STANFORD, 62

 Scheme size: $7 billion

Charges: 14 fraud-related counts

Disposition: Convicted, sentenced to 110 years in federal prison

The skinny: The Antiguan knight/Texan financier always paid out higher-than-market returns on his South Floridian investors’ money.

KENNETH THENEN, 75

 Scheme size: $300 million

Charges: Wire fraud and money laundering

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to 10 years in federal prison

The skinny: Operated a grocery-trading scheme in the ’90s that ensnared some 1,800 well-heeled investors — including Joe DiMaggio.

LUIS FELIPE PEREZ, 40

 Scheme size: $40 million

Charges: Securities fraud, conspiracy to commit bank fraud

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to 10 years in federal prison

The skinny: Used his ties in the Cuban community to convince investors to buy “no-risk loans” in his jewelry businesses. His diamonds were fakes.

THE ORLANSKY BROTHERS

 Scheme size: $165 million

Charges: Bank and wire fraud, money laundering

Disposition: Convicted, sentenced to 20 years in federal prison

The skinny: Through their factoring firm, E.S. Bankest, Eduardo, 74, and Hector, 67, ripped off their clients by inflating the value of collateral. The scam collapsed in 2003.

GASTON E. CANTENS, 73

 Scheme size: $135 million

Charges: Conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to five years in federal prison

The skinny: The Miami real estate developer used his connections at Belen Jesuit to lure in Cuban-American investors, falsely guaranteeing huge returns.

GEORGE THEODULE, 51

 Alleged haul: $68 million

Charges: None

SEC case: Agreed to a final judgment of $5.6 million in penalties

The skinny: Lured fellow Haitian Americans into his get-rich investment clubs with a promise of stunning returns – and told them that God was on their side.

LEWIS FREEMAN, 63

 Scheme size: $2.6 million

Charges: Mail fraud

Disposition: Pleaded guilty, sentenced to eight years in federal prison

The skinny: A once-prominent forensic accountant who stole millions from clients: 14 fiduciary accounts over a 10-year period.

GEORGE ELIA, 68

 Alleged haul: $11 million

Charges: Wire fraud

Disposition: Awaiting trial

The skinny: Investment manager who targeted Wilton Manors’ gay community. Elia moved out of his home abruptly and temporarily fled the country, but later returned.


abeasley@MiamiHerald.com

It’s not entirely clear if the increase in Ponzi arrests has been due to more Ponzis actually taking place, or simply more coming to the attention of authorities due to the brutal economic times. Madoff’s $65 billion scheme — the largest in American history — unraveled only because the stock market crashed in 2008, and his investors tried to pull out their money. He didn’t have it.

TARGETING THOSE WHO ARE LIKE YOU

Locally, Gaston E. and Teresita Cantens are among those targeted in recent years by the SEC’s Miami branch. The local real estate developers defrauded more than 400 investors by offering bogus promissory notes claiming annual returns of 9 to 16 percent, the commission says.

In all, their scheme totaled $135 million, much of which came from fellow graduates and supporters of Gaston Cantens’ alma mater, Belen Jesuit Preparatory School. Along with the SEC suit, Gaston Cantens, 73, pleaded guilty to mail and wire fraud. He is currently serving a five-year stint in a low-security prison in North Carolina.

Cantens followed a now-familiar fraudulent blueprint: Target those who are like you — and, by extension, trust you. He went after fellow Cuban Americans.

Eduardo Arango, 80, invested more than $800,000 — money from the sale of his house, and nearly his entire life savings — in Cantens’ business. He got just $24,000 of that back in bankruptcy court. Now, Arango’s home is a rental property in Kendall, and he lives far more modestly than before he got mixed up with Cantens. He drives cheaper cars, and can’t take vacations.

“I’m still angry; I don’t forgive him at all,” said Arango. “He didn’t mind taking everything from his friends.”

Even Belen got fleeced, losing a half-million dollars in the Ponzi.

Madoff, whose enterprise was based in New York , not only cleaned out fellow Jews — many from Palm Beach County — but even ripped off Jewish charities.

So in this way, South Florida’s demography — and the sense of autonomy among its various ethnic groups — makes it uniquely susceptible to scammers.

And while it’s now a tired (and, to a degree, outdated) cliché that we’re the home of the blue-haired army, retirees still make up a disproportionate chunk of our population — and they have money to invest.

“Given their age and frequently their lack of sophistication of what they bring to the investment process, they always have been and continue to be a vulnerable group,” Levi said.

WHY SCAMMERS TARGET FLORIDA

Matthew Menchel was a prosecutor before switching sides. He is now a defense attorney with the global litigation boutique Kobre and Kim that deals in white-collar criminal cases, including alleged pyramid schemes.

Miami is a financially “immature” city, Menchel says. Swindles that would never fly in savvier places like New York are able to flourish here because investors concerned solely with making a quick buck don’t do the proper due diligence.

And unlike other towns, flash is in our DNA.

“It’s easier to blend in here because of the nature of how things are,” said Eric Bustillo, the SEC’s regional director.

“If a guy goes from driving a Toyota to a Ferrari over a few months, it doesn’t necessarily raise the eyebrows here it would in a place like Wisconsin.”

Read more Miami-Dade stories from the Miami Herald

  • Columnist

    Church baseball league’s longtime leader retires

    Seventeen years ago, Bob Haworth, a member of Grace Lutheran Church in Miami Springs, organized a coed softball league. And for all of those years, Haworth has served as the commissioner. Comes this summer, the good commissioner will move to Winter Haven, where his wife Diane, has started a new career.

  • In my opinion

    Daniel Shoer Roth: Hialeah ‘boletera’ a political scapegoat in ballot scandal

    Since the eruption of the electoral fraud volcano last summer, Hialeah ballot broker Deisy Pentón de Cabrera has been depicted by the authorities and the media as Snow White’s Queen Grimhilde transformed into a witch. Her basket hides not only a poisoned apple, but a complete harvest that, with the scandal’s shooting lava, has become rotten applesauce.

  •  

This 1972 Miami Herald photo shows Mike Burke, founder of Windjammer Barefoot Cruises.

    DEATHS

    Capt. Mike Burke, Windjammer founder, dies at 89

    Capt. Michael Burke sailed through life with his unending spirit and romantic outlook, touching the lives of many with his cruise empire, Windjammer Barefoot Cruises.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category