Andres Oppenheimer

In My Opinion

Argentina’s economic fiesta is over

 

aoppenheimer@MiamiHerald.com

miamiherald.com/andres_oppenheimer/

For a visitor returning here after a 10-month absence, it is amazing how fast things have changed: the biggest economic bonanza in this country’s recent history has suddenly turned into a sharp downturn, and optimism has given way to general anxiety, if not panic.

Argentina’s eight-year-long fiesta is over.

Despite President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner’s passionate speeches claiming that her late husband President Nestor Kirchner discovered a new nationalist economic model that brought record growth rates of 8 percent annually during much of the past decade — albeit growth that most economists attribute to outside factors, such as China’s massive purchases of this country’s grain exports — signs of the end of the boom everywhere.

Fernández’s popularity rate has fallen from a massive 63 percent after winning reelection in October to 39 percent today, according to a new Management & Fit poll. While her recent nationalization of YPF, the country’s biggest oil company, brought her a brief uptick in the polls, pot-banging protests in this capital’s wealthiest neighborhoods are increasing.

What’s more threatening to the government is that the country’s biggest labor union — CGT, until recently a close government ally — has begun escalating its protests and is demanding a 30 percent wage increase. Agricultural producers’ organizations also are threatening nationwide strikes against the government’s escalating taxes on grain exports.

The talk of the day in Buenos Aires is where to buy U.S. dollars in the black market, and at what exchange rate. Inflation, officially at 9 percent, is almost unanimously estimated at 25 percent. Fearing an economic crack that will result in hyperinflation, people are buying U.S. dollars on the streets from black market foreign exchange vendors standing on the corners, who are appropriately known as arbolitos or little trees.

After several years during which Fernández bragged that Argentina was one of the world’s most rapidly growing economies while the United States and Europe were crumbling, Argentina’s economy is now projected to slow down from nearly 9 percent last year to 2.2 percent this year, according to the latest World Bank estimates. Many independent economists say that even that projection is too optimistic, and that the country may end this year with a recession.

“We think the story ends with a large devaluation sooner or later,” said a recent report by UBS bank economist Javier Kulesz, who added that it would come along with a large increase in public utility prices, heightened social tensions, and low if not negative growth. “This is nothing Argentines aren’t familiar with. They have seen this movie in its various versions quite a few times over the past few decades,” he said.

Why did Argentina’s economy take such a sudden turn downwards? China has not stopped buying Argentine commodities, there has been no tsunami or earthquake that has crippled this country’s infrastructure, nor any international economic crisis that has hurt Argentina more than others. On the contrary, the international environment continues to be favorable to this country, as commodity prices remain relatively high, and many international investors disillusioned with Europe’s recession are increasingly looking at Latin America as an option.

Judging from dozens of interviews here last week, there is only one reason for Argentina’s current decline — and it’s the usual one. It’s politics, of course.

Fernández de Kirchner’s populist government has given away massive subsidies in its quest to win elections, much like Hugo Chávez in Venezuela. While ever-growing subsidies work while commodity exports keep rising, they can leave a country bankrupt once world commodity prices stop growing.

While neighboring Chile under both center-left and center-right governments has saved in good years to maintain its social programs during bad years, Argentina has done exactly the opposite. It has squandered what economists say was its biggest economic bonanza in nearly a century in giving government jobs to loyalists, cash subsidies to millions of people — many of whom now find it more convenient to live from government handouts than to find a job — and transportation and energy subsidies.

Thanks to government subsidies, public transportation in Buenos Aires may be among the cheapest in the world: a bus ride costs the equivalent of U.S. 22 cents, and a train ride U.S. 26 cents.

Roberto Lavagna — the former economy minister under Nestor Kirchner who is credited with resurrecting Argentina’s economy after the country’s 2001 default on its foreign debts — estimates that government subsidies for transportation and energy soared from U.S. $1.2 billion at the end of 2005 to U.S. $19 billion last year.

While commonsense would suggest that Fernández de Kirchner would start reducing public spending in light of the economic slowdown, she seems to be doubling her bets. Last week, she announced a giant plan to give out 400,000 low-interest mortgages and build 400,000 homes over the next four years.

Where will the money come from? It will be borrowed from the state’s Social Security System. The government says the plan will create 100,000 jobs in construction work, and help reactivate the economy. Skeptics say the money will disappear in the hands of corrupt officials, like so many times before, and future retirees will not see a penny of their pensions.

“They have a very short-term, strictly political vision of the economy,” Lavagna said. “That’s very unlikely to change.”

What’s most worrisome is that a large number or Argentines, while increasingly skeptical about Fernández de Kirchner’s narrative about the alleged new economic model, are not necessarily opposed to a growing state role in the economy, Lavagna said.

“There is a growing statist trend, which is very accepted by society,” Lavagna said. “The latest polls show that Argentines support statist policies by a margin of two to one.”

My opinion: All indications are that Fernández de Kirchner will blame the outside world — the media, Greece or Washington — for the downturn caused by her own irresponsible economic fiesta. She will print increasingly more money to buy votes to win the October, 2013 legislative elections, if they are not held earlier, and will pray for a new spike of world commodity prices — which very few are predicting — to rescue the country’s balance sheet.

In the process, she will have squandered Argentina’s best opportunity in a century to use its commodity bonanza for improving education standards, attracting investments to create new industries, and lifting millions of people from poverty for good.

I hope I’m wrong about this, and that during the 3.5 years remaining in her term, Fernández de Kirchner she will take a more long-term, less ideological, view of what’s best for her country. But I didn’t hear anything during my stay here to convince me that she will do anything to save Argentina from its self-inflicted crisis.

Read more Andres Oppenheimer stories from the Miami Herald

  • In My Opinion

    Andres Oppenheimer: While Pacific Alliance thrives, Mercosur withers

    Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos may not have been hallucinating when he said last week that the Pacific Alliance — the bloc made up of Mexico, Colombia, Peru and Chile — “is the new economic and development engine of Latin America and the Caribbean.”

  • In My Opinion

    Andres Oppenheimer: OAS report breaks ground on marijuana

    Latin American presidents who support decriminalization of marijuana won a big diplomatic victory in recent days when the 34-country Organization of American States issued a report that considers that option as one of several policies that might help reduce the region’s drug-related violence.

  • The Oppenheimer Report

    Andres Oppenheimer: World science map grim for Latin America

    The highly respected Nature Scientific Reports journal has just published a map of the world’s leading science cities, and it looks pretty bad for emerging countries: It shows the planet’s northern hemisphere full of lights, and the south almost solidly dark.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category