First person

Anti-tumor meds for breast cancer patients come with scary history

 

atorres@miamiherald.com

While juggling the side effects of breast cancer treatment, I have heard this reasoning multiple times: The benefits greatly outweigh the risks. I’m not so sure the logic always works.

The next phase of my treatment includes taking a drug for five years that the American Cancer Society has deemed a human carcinogen, a substance that is directly involved in causing cancer. The drug is called Tamoxifen, sold as Nolvadex, Istubal and Valodex. The list of carcinogens also includes a leisurely day in Miami Beach: solar radiation, tobacco and alcoholic beverages.

“It is certain that if we put you on a medicine like Tamoxifen, we will dramatically further decrease your chance of recurrence,” said the University of Miami Sylvester Cancer Center’s Dr. Marc Lippman, chairman of the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine.

I trust Lippman. He is a pioneering breast cancer researcher, who understands the kind of tumors that were found in my left breast, which tested positive for estrogen and progesterone, the female hormones produced in the ovaries. The “anti-tumor” medicine he recommends is meant to fool the voracious appetite of the molecular monsters – which could be lurking in my chest wall.

“Tamoxifen is one of the safest drugs we have,” said Lippman. “It doesn’t cause any heart, lung, liver, kidney, brain, bonemarrow damage … believe it or not taking your Tamoxifen every day is worth as much to you than all the radiation and all the chemotherapy that you have had."

But the more I was learning about Tamoxifen, the more I felt like a scared tight ropewalker. The drug was born in an environment where patents allow legal monopolies to keep prices high and restrict competition. This environnment has often led to accusations that drug companies have withheld information about the risks of taking certain medications.

Imperial Chemical Industries, a former British chemical company, discovered Tamoxifen in 1978 and patented it in the U.S. in 1985. Seven years later, a district court judge declared the patent invalid based on the conclusion that ICI had deliberately withheld “crucial information’’ regarding tests that it had conducted on laboratory animals. The tests had revealed hormonal effects “opposite to those sought in humans,’’ which, the court found, could have “unpredictable and at times disastrous consequences.’’

ICI filed an appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals, and in 1993, struck down the district court’s judgement that the patent was invalid. ICI eventually transferred the patent to pharmaceutical giant AstraZeneca, which now sells the widely prescribed drug. In recent cases involving another one of its products, AstraZeneca was accused of not disclosing studies that revealed serious risks. According to company e-mails unsealed in pending civil lawsuits against AstraZeneca, employees dealing with unfavorable studies engaged in doing a “great smoke-and-mirrors job” to market their product to doctors and patients.

During a press conference in 2010, Kathleen Sebelius, the secretary of health and human services, said AstraZeneca paid kickbacks to doctors as part of an illegal scheme to market drugs for unapproved uses.” AstraZeneca denied wrongdoing and paid $520 million to settle the federal investigations.

The cases are unrelated to Tamoxifen, which is marketed to have significantly reduced breast cancer recurrences for decades around the world. The uncomfortable side effects reported include menopause-like symptoms. The more serious side effects include thromboembolism, the formation of a bloodclot, which can lead to a heart attack or stroke.

“It has about the same risk of bloodclots of being on an oral contraceptive or having been pregnant, so it ’s very small,” said Lippman. “In younger women who are of ideal weight, and who are active – the risk is almost zero.”

Studies have shown that Tamoxifen acts like an anti-estrogen in the breast, and may act like estrogen in other tissues, such as the lining of the uterus.

“One woman in 150, so that’s less than one percent, can get endometrial cancer, cancer from the uterus,” said Lippman. “We always have you followed by gynecological exams, and the lethality is zero. Zero. So that the only risk is that rarely — and I have had this happen once in my entire practice — a woman has had to have a hysterectomy.”

Women die in this war. Lippman has the heart and determination of a captain in the U.S. Naval Reserve, and speaks with the confidence of a Yale School of Medicine graduate who has seen it all. So when armageddon hit five months ago, I promised myself that I would do my best to muster the courage to follow his lead.

“You may well be completely disease free … there is no test that we have for you right now that would allow us to know if there is a cancer cell in your body,’’ said Lippman. “I want to emphasize that the therapy you have been given is with curative intent, and in my view you are more likely to be cured than not.”

“O.K. I guess time will tell,” I said.

And in what appeared to be an act of camaraderie, he said, “Time will tell for all of us. Nobody is gettting out of this place alive.”

MY JOURNEY

Part 1: At age 33, I’m dealing with breast cancer

Part 2: Cancer treatment complicates dreams of pregnancy

Part 3: Hanging in when chemotherapy gets rough

Part 4: Tough surgery choices: Mastectomy vs. Lumpectomy

Part 5: Silicone implans are not the only way to go in breast reconstruction

Part 6: Rebuilding the breast from body tissue

Part 7: Body fat can be used to build breast

Part 8: Facing my fears after mastectomy

Part 9: Taking control of the fear that comes with breast cancer

Part 10: Doctor knows about being a breast cancer survivor

Part 11: Radiation therapy gives her hope

Part 12: Finding strength from others

Part 13: Facebook, medication help breast cancer patient deal with depression

Part 14: A new outlook on 2012

Part 15: Breast cancer patient faces genetic mystery

Part 16: Using diversion to cope with harsh reality

Part 17: After radiation therapy ends

Part 18: Friend’s breast cancer journey is not as fortunate

Read more Health stories from the Miami Herald

  •  
The Knight Plaza where the outdoor seating doubles as planters at the Perez Art Museum Miami.

    HIV/AIDS FUNDRAISERS

    Thirtieth anniversary White Party 2014 to be Nov. 29 at Perez Art Museum Miami

    White Party, the annual HIV/AIDS fundraiser for Care Resource, moves this November to Miami’s new art museum on the bay.

  • Ask Nancy

    Ask Nancy: My mother won’t listen to her doctors

    Q. My sister and I are constantly taking my 86-year-old mother to the doctor for her real and/or imagined problems and the doctor will make suggestions or prescribe treatments. She either disagrees with what the doctor says and requests to see a different doctor, or decides that she doesn’t want to do the treatment or take the medicine. How do we get her to comply with what the doctors prescribe?

  • Skin Deep

    The connection between lymph and how you look

    You’ve surely heard the word “lymph” or are familiar with the concept of “lymphatic drainage,” but do you really know what this is and what it means for your appearance?

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category