From Our Inbox

  • Logout
  • Member Center

Gingrich’s swipes at food stamps whiz past the truth

 

In South Carolina, Newt Gingrich won a standing ovation at the Fox News-Wall Street Journal debate by calling President Obama “the best food-stamp president in American history” and claiming that the program breeds dependency on the federal government among indolent minorities. He flatly rejected a moderator’s suggestion that he was propagating a vile racial stereotype. “We ((Republicans)) believe in work,” he said afterward. “We believe people should learn to work and that we’re opposed to dependency.”

Gingrich’s preferred means of instilling the work ethic that he claims is missing among young minorities is to assign them janitorial jobs.

For Gingrich, none of this is new — neither the attacks on food stamps, the suggestion that they mainly benefit African Americans nor the pious dismissal of his critics as craven elites reluctant to face hard truths. Back when he was still serving in Congress, Republicans routinely disparaged food stamp recipients as unscrupulous welfare queens in Cadillacs who were engaged, as Sen. Jesse Helms put it, in“a multibillion-dollar shakedown of the American taxpayers.”

In 1994, Gingrich sought to eliminate the federal food stamp entitlement as part of his Contract With America, using the same reasoning he employed on Monday night.

But while Gingrich’s attacks on food stamps and those who use them are essentially the same ones he and his colleagues were making two decades ago, the profile of the recipients has changed a great deal since then — and in a direction that Gingrich should applaud were his true motivation, as he claims, to encourage blacks to “demand paychecks and not be satisfied with food stamps.”

First, some facts: The number of food stamp recipients has indeed risen sharply, but this rise began under President George W. Bush and is largely attributable to the recession. Food stamps are an anti-poverty measure, so it’s no surprise that enrollment should rise when large numbers of people are out of work (the number of recipients dropped last month as the economy improved). But recession isn’t the only cause. A Bush administration initiative begun in 2002 dramatically increased participation rates among eligible households, from 48 percent to 72 percent in 2009. And a law signed by Ronald Reagan allows the federal government to provide food stamps to disaster victims (including those who are not poor), as it did last year after Hurricane Irene and Tropical Storm Lee.

The idea that the program caters mainly to blacks disinclined to work is wrong in several respects. By most estimates, African Americans make up about 33 percent of recipients. Overwhelmingly, food stamps go to children, the elderly or the severely disabled. The biggest change over the past 20 years is that the share of working households with children has doubled to just under half of all recipients — a number that has held up during the recession.

”In the past, many people thought that if they were working they didn’t qualify for food stamps,” says Dorothy Rosenbaum, a senior policy analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.“But it’s really a work-support program that can boost the wages of participating families.” In fact, the benefit is designed to encourage work, diminishing only gradually as income rises so that recipients aren’t forced to choose between food stamps and work.

This has had the salutary effect not only of helping to feed the hungry but of lifting many working households out of poverty. Consider the case of a family of three whose single working member earns $10 an hour — roughly the wage of a janitor. According to calculations by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, if the janitor worked 30 hours a week, the food-stamp benefit would increase the family’s income by 38 percent. Taking that additional income into account, the Census Bureau estimates that food stamps kept 3.9 million people above the poverty line in 2010.

In other words, far from breeding dependence, the program supports and encourages exactly the type of character-building work that Gingrich says he is trying to foster. A policy wonk and a notorious pedant, he surely understands this. So it’s all the more damning that his caricature of the program doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

Joshua Green is a national correspondent at Bloomberg Businessweek.

(c) 2011 The Boston Globe
dealsaver
The Miami Herald: Subscribe now!

More from
From Our Inbox

  • Five dictators with mommy issues

    The Austrian neurologist Sigmund Freud, who was very close with his mother, once remarked that “people who know that they are preferred or favored by their mother give evidence in their lives of a peculiar self-reliance and an unshakeable optimism which often seem like heroic attributes and bring actual success to their possessors.”

  • How super-PACs will keep the presidential race clean

    Strangely enough, the 2012 presidential campaign, expected to be the dirtiest in modern memory, may end up being relatively clean.

  • Our love of driving is decelerating

    Good news for Memorial Day weekend: Since peaking at a national average of $3.93 on April 5, the price of regular gasoline has fallen almost 25 cents per gallon. That’s like a $25 billion tax cut for consumers. In fact, gasoline is cheaper now than it was a year ago at this time. Futures markets are signaling further possible declines.

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

We have introduced a new commenting system called Disqus for our articles. This allows readers the option of signing in using their Facebook, Twitter, Disqus or existing MiamiHerald.com username and password.

Having problems? Read more about the commenting system on MiamiHerald.com.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK
0 comments

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category