Other Views

  • Logout
  • Member Center

ABORTION DEBATE

It’s time for the annual ‘Roe’ carnival

 

danamilbank@washpost.com

Abortion provider Merle Hoffman called a news conference at the National Press Club this week to announce the results of an alarming new study she commissioned:

Abortion rates have exploded since the economic collapse, she warned, as nearly three-quarters of women ending their pregnancies say they simply can’t afford to have a baby. Hoffman expanded on these trends to forecast a “dim future” for women if a Republican wins the White House: a world of abortion “slave states” and “underground railroads” and “pre-Roe reality.”

There was just one problem with this hysteria: The data in the study she presented were from 2008 — before the impact of the recession was felt. The sweeping conclusions came, rather, from “journalistic reports,” as well as studies at Hoffman’s own clinic in New York — where, she eventually admitted, abortion rates were “relatively stable” the last two years.

Dubious statistics? Calling a news conference to tell reporters about conclusions reached by reading newspapers? This can mean only one thing: It’s Roe week in the capital.

The annual carnival in Washington around the Jan. 22 anniversary of the Roe v. Wade decision (Happy 39th, Roe!) has become more farcical with each repetition. As technology and states’ policy changes make the landmark case less important, the annual observances of the anniversary have devolved into fact-free spectacles that have less to do with abortion than with raising money for advocacy groups on both sides.

The gruesome photos of fetuses and the guys in Grim Reaper costumes will be out, as usual, for Monday’s “March for Life,” which, according to the organizers, will “follow its customary route.” The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, piggybacking on the march, has a National Prayer Vigil on Sunday. Not to be outdone, the Archdiocese of Washington has a “Youth Rally and Mass for Life” planned for Monday, which shouldn’t be confused with the march organizers’ own “Youth Rally” on Saturday. The “Rose Dinner” (tickets $100 at the door) is Monday night (”Donate Now!” it says near the top of the march’s website).

Operation Rescue is participating in a Students for Life of America National Youth Conference in North Bethesda, Md., on Sunday, although this would appear to conflict with the annual Charismatic Episcopal Church for Life Youth Rally in Washington. The president of Americans United for Life will be having breakfast with reporters on Friday, and the Family Research Council is staging “the premier conference for the online pro-life community” on Monday (”Donate today”!).

On the other side, the National Organization for Women is having its Supreme Court Vigil on Monday. NARAL Pro-Choice America has called Jan. 22 “Blog for Choice Day,” and has scheduled its “Roe v. Wade 39th Anniversary Dinner” for Jan. 26. If you buy a “power table” at the dinner for a mere $15,000, you’ll get to hear “Curb Your Enthusiasm’s” Susie Essman, known for her “hilarious bouts of withering sarcasm and uninhibited insults.”

Here’s an uninhibited insult the professional “life” and“choice” agitators can listen to for free. If these groups cared as much about the issue as they claim — and didn’t have such strong financial incentives to avoid consensus and compromise — they’d cancel the carnivals and get to work on the one thing everybody agrees would be worthwhile: reducing unwanted pregnancies.

If the “life” marchers really wanted fewer abortions, they would stop throwing obstacles in the way of birth control and make sure it’s cheaply provided as part of preventive care and not blocked by “conscience clauses.” By resisting easy birth control, and by opposing comprehensive sex education, they’re essentially increasing abortion rates.

If the “choice” rally participants really want to preserve legal abortion, they’d be wise to drop the sky-is-falling warnings about Roe and acknowledge that the other side — and most Americans — has legitimate concerns. Not every compromise means a slippery slope to the back alley.

But this is no time for reason; this is time for collecting donations. At the Press Club, abortion-provider Hoffman gave a full-throated defense of her own abortion (”I had committed myself to my work” and didn’t want to be “diverted”), coupled with dire warnings about the future of legal abortion. Hoffman likened her defense of the procedure to Martin Luther’s 95 Theses. “Abortion is a life-affirming act,” she said, and “abortion is often the most moral choice.”

Abortion as a “most moral” and “life-affirming” choice: It’s beginning to feel a lot like Roe week in Washington.

© 2012, Washington Post Writers Group
dealsaver
The Miami Herald: Subscribe now!

More from
Other Views

  • MUSIC

    Disco was so much more than just a fad

    As news of the deaths of Disco Queen Donna Summer and the Bee Gees’ Robin Gibb circulated the entertainment world, the passing of the two disco icons carried a particular and personal sting for Miamians.

  •  

TRISTAM

    UNIVERSITY BUDGETS

    Why I’m relieved my daughter won’t be a Gator

    As many parents know, April can be the cruelest month, breeding college rejection letters from across the land. My daughter Sadie, who’s completed the IB program at Flagler Palm Coast High School, had high hopes. But she was wait-listed at her four top choices, all four out of state. She finally enrolled, to her great disappointment and ours, at the University of Florida. Then last week Grinnell College in Iowa called. Sadie was off the wait list. She was in. Not only that: She was granted a full ride and then some. Just as important: She got her visa out of Florida.

  •  

DVORAK

    WEDDED BLISS

    On marriage menu, compromise the main dish

    It’s not so much a philosophical issue with the Grand Slam. Or a quibble with the basic theory behind Moons Over My Hammy.

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

We have introduced a new commenting system called Disqus for our articles. This allows readers the option of signing in using their Facebook, Twitter, Disqus or existing MiamiHerald.com username and password.

Having problems? Read more about the commenting system on MiamiHerald.com.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK
0 comments

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category