Broward

  • Logout
  • Member Center

Broward County

Broward demands U.S. justify the use of airport X-ray scanners on passengers

 

Citing the European Union’s recent decision to ban the use of such scanners at security checkpoints, county commissioners asked federal authorities to prove they are safe or else stop using them.

Sun Sentinel

Federal officials insisted Tuesday that X-ray scanners used at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport are safe for travelers, but Broward County commissioners are not convinced.

On a split vote Tuesday, a majority of commissioners asked the U.S. Transportation Security Administration to do more to assure Broward’s travelers that the X-ray scanners are safe, or to ban them if they are not.

The county’s request of the TSA: Find the studies that prompted Europe to ban the scanners, and explain why the TSA agrees or disagrees with them; determine whether frequent fliers are at a higher cancer risk from passing through the scanners, and if so, post alerts at the airport that tell them how many scans a week might be safe; and if the TSA finds the European Union’s studies show a heightened risk, consider banning the use of the backscatter scanners here.

With those actions, Broward County and its airport become the first in the United States to take a stand in an international debate about the so-called “backscatter” airport security scanners, which some studies say would cause cancer in a few travelers out of the millions who fly each year.

Only 40 airports in the United States have the controversial backscatter machines, which use low-level ionic X-ray beams, the TSA said. Sixty more, including airports in Miami-Dade and Palm Beach counties, have scanners that use millimeter wave technology — low-level radio waves that are considered safe.

County Commissioner Ilene Lieberman said she did not trust the government’s assurances and studies because history is full of examples of products the public was told were safe, but turned out not to be.

The government once approved saccharin and red food dye for public consumption, and asbestos was routinely used for insulation, she said, but all were found to cause cancer and pulled from the market.

Mayor John Rodstrom, a frequent flier who brought the item forward, said that despite the time he spent over the past week with TSA officials, he’s “still not sold.”

“I’m already getting bombarded with all this radiation,” he said. “I don’t want any more.”

The county’s move this month was prompted by the Nov. 14 edict of the European Union, which said that “in order not to risk jeopardizing citizens’ health and safety, only security scanners which do not use X-ray technology” can be used to screen passengers there.

TSA local Federal Security Director Tim Lewis spoke publicly Tuesday, reading from a lengthy statement citing numerous studies that found the X-ray levels fall under the thresholds for concern. He repeated the agency’s oft-cited statistic: that the dose is the radiation equivalent of about two minutes of flying at an airliner’s cruising altitude.

“TSA would not use technology that could jeopardize the health of passengers or our employees,” he said.

Earlier this month, ProPublica/PBS NewsHour reported that the TSA had downplayed research that said the scanners could lead to a small number of cancer cases. The investigative reports questioned why the agency uses the X-ray scanners instead of solely using the radio-wave machines, which the TSA says are equally effective in detecting explosives a passenger might be carrying.

Tuesday’s vote in favor was: Mayor John Rodstrom and commissioners Ilene Lieberman, Dale Holness, Sue Gunzburger and Lois Wexler. Against, and favoring the status quo: Kristin Jacobs, Chip LaMarca, Barbara Sharief and Stacy Ritter.

Ritter said she hated to “sound like a Republican here, in fact it kills me,” but “there is some personal responsibility here.”

If travelers study the issue and decide they don’t want to go through the scanners, they don’t have to. They can opt for a thorough pat-down.

She said she trusted what the TSA said.

“Are you going to throw out every study because there’s one you don’t like?” she asked. “Are we as government officials going to say we don’t believe government? Well, I won’t say that.”

dealsaver
The Miami Herald: Subscribe now!

More from
Broward

  • In My Opinion

    College loans are next debt crisis

    Marlins Park, financed by bonds that will take four decades and $2.4 billion to pay off, makes a perfect setting for commencement exercises. Vice President Joe Biden, when he addresses a happy throng of graduates from Cypress Bay High School in that fancy new baseball stadium on June 4, will be looking out at the unwitting perpetrators of the next great debt crisis.

  • Trayvon Martin case

    Witnesses in Trayvon Martin case contradict, change their stories

    Several witnesses in the Trayvon Martin case changed their accounts after weeks of intense media coverage, according to recordings released by the prosecution.

  • Plantation: Two bodies found in submerged car in canal

    Two bodies were found inside a submerged car in a canal in Plantation Friday afternoon, according to Plantation police.

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

We have introduced a new commenting system called Disqus for our articles. This allows readers the option of signing in using their Facebook, Twitter, Disqus or existing MiamiHerald.com username and password.

Having problems? Read more about the commenting system on MiamiHerald.com.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK
0 comments

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category